After watching this, some people asked what I meant about all the elements “looking like they’re from different games.” One thing that’s always irked me a bit about the New Super Mario Bros. series is the art direction. Something’s always seemed… unfocused. Old and new enemies don’t seem to follow the same design rules. Characters looks very three dimensional, but environments and backgrounds have a very flat look. Certain effects look a little too realistic to work with the rest of the world. It’s not bad design, it’s not bad art- it’s just missing that 10% that unifies things and takes them from “good” to “great.”
The biggest addition the Wii U hardware brings- aside from HD visuals- is the use of the GamePad in multiplayer. The assist mode is a neat idea, but just like everything else in the franchise’s multiplayer modes, it’s a bit uneven. The idea of helpful platforms being placed when needed it great, but in actual execution it’s a bit frustrating. Timing and placement are a little too hard for the sort of player who’s going to be attracted filling that position.
The Challenge Modes are an interesting addition we didn’t touch on in the video review. Different challenges teach you to speed run, use your jumping skills, and generally just hone your abilities. I dug it, but the one mode I’ve wanted from NSMB from the start still isn’t there: the knockout battle mode of Super Mario Bros 3. Anyone who played Florian Hufsky’s brilliant homebrew classic Super Mario War will understand how much fun a single-screen, 4-player all out battle in a Mario game can be. Here’s a video for the uninitiated:
Come on. Look at that. That’s a lot of fun. I know you can be combative in the co-op mode of NSMB, but I actually dislike that. I feel like it undermines the expectation of a co-op mode entirely and it just feels weird. Give me an actual sandbox for that kind of play.
In terms of the co-op itself, I would love to see an option to turn off collision between players and the freezing that happens when anyone gets hurt or picks up a power up. It’s not a useful indicator of anything for other players and can actually throw off their rhythm quite a bit, meaning one death often causes a chain reaction.
I wanted to make sure we had that note at the end about this not being a review of the Wii U itself or what type of Mario title we expected for a launch. I just wanted to take the game on its own. But a lot of people have commented and asked about those thing, so here you are: no, I don’t really see this as a system seller. If you know you’re getting a Wii U, this is a great game to have. If you were on the fence about the Wii U, this isn’t the game that’s going to get you into the launch lines tonight to buy one. I really wish we had something that’s a continuation of 64/Sunshine/Galaxy… or even an HD version of this year’s Mario 3D Land.
I don’t see it as a great way to show off the GamePad or the hardware of the Wii U. In his first draft of the review Miguel called it a “system justifier,” which I think is more accurate. Once I was sat down in front of it, I had fun. Of course I did, it’s a Mario game. But you had to put it front of me. I didn’t go running after it. I don’t think that’s a problem for Nintendo based on those launch lines and backorder queues, but there are those of us out there that are still scratching our heads over the Wii U- and New Super Mario Bros. U won’t help that.
The Wii U is almost here and with it comes a whole heap of launch titles, which got us thinking: what are the best launch titles ever?
Nothing shall remain trapped in a box as long as I’m around. I will set you free, Pro Controller. I will set you free.
There was a Wii U in a box. I took it right the fuck out of that box. Believe.
Halo 4 has arrived, and with it comes our review. Does 343 Industries fill the huge shoes of Bungie and set the stage for a new trilogy of games?
Remember the Neo Geo? The console you always wanted, but could never afford? To celebrate the 20th anniversary of the classic system, Neo Geo is releasing it alongside 20 classic games! I got a chance to go hands on with the Neo Geo X Gold Limited Edition bundle and try out some of the games for himself. CLICK CLICK CLICK
Halloween is almost here, and you know what’s scarier than “scary” video games? FULL MOTION VIDEO video games. Those things are terrifying. So in honor of the spookiest holiday of the year, we welcomed CollegeHumor’s Jeff Rubin into the office to run down the “top” 5 FMV games from the worst game genre of all time.
Game companies are putting more and more effort into big budget trailers, but have they gone too far? This week the gang (minus Tara, plus Jackie) discusses exactly that, pondering what makes for a good video game trailer. And of course, there’s an inevitable video game to movie comparison.
It was a bummer to shut New Challenger down, but it wasn’t a hard decision. The show had some bright points, but ultimately none of them required the weekly series format. Also, if I had to be completely honest, I wasn’t into the weekly show format myself. I don’t like producing for a standard studio show. It’s not my thing.
I learned a lot making New Challenger and got to work with and meet a lot of insanely talented people. It was a lot of fun.
Also, after making this I decided I might be better at canceling shows than producing them. I really like this video. A lot. I finally got to live my dream of walking into the ocean in a shirt and tie at the end of a short film.
Dishonored is out this week, and a lot of people are really concerned about the game’s length. This got the gang thinking – how long should games be?